What Are Probiotics and Do They Actually Work?

Probiotics are live microorganisms, usually friendly bacteria like Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium that, when consumed in the right amounts, are meant to bring health benefits to their host. These helpful microbes help balance the ecosystem of our gut, support digestion, assist in nutrient absorption, and interact with our immune system in subtle but powerful ways¹. 

Where Do They Come From? 

You’ve likely encountered probiotics in yoghurt, kefir, and fermented foods like kimchi and sauerkraut. You might also find them in supplement aisles, where capsules and powders promise better digestion and stronger immunity. But here’s the thing: not all probiotic strains are equal. The effectiveness of any probiotic hinges on its strain, the dosage, and crucially how it's delivered. Some strains may never make it past your stomach acid, while others may simply be under-researched or mismatched to your unique microbiome². 

What Is a Probiotic Strain? 

The term "strain" refers to a specific subtype of a bacterial species. Think of it like this: just as there are different breeds of dogs within the species Canis familiaris, there are different strains within probiotic species like Lactobacillus acidophilus. Each strain can behave differently, with unique health effects, survivability, and mechanisms of action. For example, Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG may help with gut barrier function, while Bifidobacterium lactis HN019 supports bowel regularity. When choosing a probiotic, knowing the strain is just as important as knowing the species. 

What Do Probiotics Actually Do?

Probiotics are multitaskers within the gut. Here’s what they help with:

• Balancing the ratio of harmful and beneficial bacteria
• Supporting digestion and helping reduce bloating
• Producing SCFAs (short-chain fatty acids) that nourish gut cells
• Interacting with the gut lining³ to regulate immune responses 

Beyond digestion, probiotics also play a role in the intricate communication pathways known as the Gut-X axis. This includes the gut-brain axis, which influences mood and mental clarity; the gut-skin axis, impacting inflammation and breakouts; and even the gut-hormone axis, which affects everything from stress regulation to metabolic balance. So while probiotics might start in the digestive tract, their benefits ripple throughout the body in unexpected and essential ways 

Why Probiotics Sometimes Fail 

Here’s where the optimism meets reality: many probiotics never make it to where they need to go. In fact, research shows that up to 90% of probiotic bacteria are destroyed by stomach acid before they can reach the colon⁴. This means your carefully chosen capsule could be offering less benefit than you hoped. Add to that poor strain selection, missing prebiotics for nourishment, and the absence of postbiotic support, and it's easy to see why results can be hit or miss. 

Do Probiotics Work at All? 

Yes, they can, when the right strain is used for the right person in the right format. For example, Lactobacillus plantarum 299v has shown positive effects in people with irritable bowel symptoms⁵. But there’s no universal probiotic that works for everyone. Results vary depending on the individual’s existing gut makeup, the quality of the product, and consistency of use. 

Conclusion 

Probiotics are a fascinating and essential part of our gut health story, but they’re only part of it. From supporting digestion to regulating immune responses and influencing our mood, skin, and hormones via the gut-x axis, their benefits are broad and real. However, they don’t always work in isolation. Without the right strain, proper delivery, and supportive elements like prebiotics and postbiotics, their impact can fall short. By understanding how probiotics work, and where they sometimes fail, you can make more empowered choices for your gut health.

References